Most orders take 8-14 business days (MON-FRI) before shipping out. Email for bulk and custom orders. Free U.S Shipping on Orders Over $70 “freeship”. Most orders take 8-14 business days (MON-FRI) before shipping out. Email for bulk and custom orders. Free U.S Shipping on Orders Over $70 “freeship”.

My cart (0)

Contact
horsetreatery@gmail.com

ALL PRODUCTS

Refine by
Sort by
Stocking Stuffers (singles)

Stocking Stuffers (singles)

From $1.26
Pony Bites Pony Bites

Pony Bites

From $8.00
Pony Pancakes Pony Pancakes

Pony Pancakes

$6.50
Pony Cupcakes Pony Cupcakes

Pony Cupcakes

$11.50
Pony Party Hats Pony Party Hats

Pony Party Hats

$8.50
Pony Presents Pony Presents

Pony Presents

$7.75
Birthday Cake Birthday Cake

Birthday Cake

$19.00
Pony Crackers Pony Crackers

Pony Crackers

$7.50

FREE SHIPPING! use code "freeship" for orders over $70

use code at checkout
Pony Gingerbread Men Pony Gingerbread Men

Pony Gingerbread Men

$6.50
Pony Christmas Trees

Pony Christmas Trees

$9.50
Pony Christmas Lights Pony Christmas Lights

Pony Christmas Lights

$9.00
Pony Ornaments

Pony Ornaments

$4.00
Pony Santa Hats

Pony Santa Hats

$8.50
Pony Stockings Pony Stockings

Pony Stockings

$7.50

Christmas Pony Cupcakes

$11.50
Christmas Pony Bites Christmas Pony Bites

Christmas Pony Bites

From $8.00
Single Pony Cracker

Single Pony Cracker

$1.90
Logo Stickers Logo Stickers

Logo Stickers

From $2.50
Logo Hats Logo Hats

Logo Hats

$34.99
Christmas Marble Pony Cupcakes

Christmas Marble Pony Cupcakes

$11.50
Hanukkah Marble Pony Muffins

Hanukkah Marble Pony Muffins

$11.50
Hanukkah Pony Cupcakes

Hanukkah Pony Cupcakes

$11.50
Funfetti Birthday Cake Funfetti Birthday Cake

Funfetti Birthday Cake

$19.00

Pony Gumdrops

$8.00
Custom Treats

Custom Treats

$65.00

Holiday Dipped Pony Muffins

$11.50